We put six virtual tape plugins head-to-head
We’re all familiar with the phrase ‘be careful what you wish for’. To read a history of the technology developed to take the world’s murkiest, earliest recordings through to the full-frequency, ultra-pristine, multi-track recordings of today is to read about ‘audio transparency’ emerging from noisy roots.
If you were to take a randomly-selected recording from each decade from 1930 onwards, what you’ll hear is increased definition and a diminishing number of ‘unwanted’ sonic artifacts, with microphone design and recording media becoming more refined.
One could argue that if pristine fidelity remains the most important requirement in modern recording, the combination of high sample rate, high sample resolution, hard-disk based recording across hundreds (even thousands!) of tracks represents the Promised Land.
But, it seems, not for all. Sales of vinyl records are at an all-time high. It’s possible to buy cassette tapes again. You might be tempted to dismiss these facts as fads but there’s a more interesting interpretation which suggests that there is an audio quality to certain recording media which is worth preserving.
In the following steps we’ll compare the (subtle) differences between a few tape emulation plugins. Listen through high quality speakers or headphones!
We start with six tracks; four are drum parts (Kick, Clap and two Hat tracks) and two are synth sequences, taken from libraries created for U-he’s Zebra by The Unfinished. We want a minimal arrangement with plenty of top and bottom end to test the tape effects we’ll add next.
Next we try the same mix but with UAD’s Studer A800 emulation inserted over the output buss. To start with, we’re choosing the Ampex 456 tape setting, allied to a tape speed of 7.5 ips (inches per second). Make sure you’re listening on high quality speakers or headphones and listen to the bottom and top ends particularly.
Compare the previous test to this one. All settings remain the same, except that we’ve increased Tape Speed to 30ips. The bass end, in particular, is warmer, more rounded and more solid, with increased clarity, definition and punch. There’s more fizz in the hats too.
By way of comparison, we bypass the UAD Studer A800 emulation and insert Slate Digital’s VTM (Virtual Tape Machines) plugin instead. We select 30ips, the 2” 16 Track Tape option and the same 456 tape type. Again, the bottom end is enhanced, though the effect here is more subtle than the A800 plugin.
The next Tape emulator we try is iZotope’s Vintage Tape plugin from Ozone 7. We add a little extra Harmonic content, add punch with the Low Emphasis control and increase Drive to match the lnput level of the competitors we’ve tried so far. Again, the bottom end responds particularly well.
In our final test, we push things a little harder using SoundToys’ Decapitator to see how tape saturation can color entire mixes. We add some Drive, then tailor the Low and High Cut dials to ensure the added Harmonics don’t overwhelm the mix. The result has much more personality (but is much less subtle!)